
Podiatrist or Orthopaedic Surgeon: How to Choose, and How to Vet a Foot Surgeon

If you have a foot or ankle problem that may need surgery, you face two questions in quick succession. Which kind of specialist should you see, and how do you tell a good one from an available one. This page covers both.
Podiatrist, podiatric surgeon, orthopaedic surgeon
A podiatrist
A doctor of podiatric medicine, trained exclusively on the foot, ankle and related structures of the leg: four years of podiatric medical school, then at least three years of medical and surgical residency. A podiatrist treats everything from calluses and ingrown toenails to fallen arches, heel spurs, deformities and injuries.
A podiatric surgeon
A podiatrist who has completed additional training across all aspects of foot and ankle surgery. Everything a podiatrist offers, plus surgical correction when conservative treatment has not resolved the problem.
An orthopaedic surgeon
A physician trained across the whole musculoskeletal system, bones, joints, ligaments, tendons and muscles throughout the body. Some orthopaedic surgeons subspecialise in the foot and ankle, and those who do bring deep experience to it. Many do not, and treat the foot as one region among many.
Which one to see
The honest answer is that the individual matters more than the category. A foot and ankle fellowship-trained orthopaedic surgeon and a board-certified podiatric surgeon are both well equipped to operate on your foot. A general orthopaedic surgeon who performs a handful of foot cases a year is a different proposition, and so is a podiatrist with no surgical training.
So the useful question is not podiatrist or orthopaedist. It is: how often does this specific surgeon perform this specific procedure, and what is their training in it.
What to check before agreeing to surgery
Board certification, and in what. For foot and ankle surgery, certification by the American Board of Foot and Ankle Surgery is the relevant credential for a podiatric surgeon. Ask which board, not just whether they are certified.
How often they perform your procedure. Volume correlates with outcomes. Ask the number, not whether they are experienced.
Whether conservative treatment was genuinely exhausted. A well-trained surgeon will not recommend an operation before non-surgical options have been tried. For plantar fasciitis, for example, that means rest, icing, night splinting, orthotics and injection therapy first. Surgery ends up being necessary for only a small minority of cases.
What the recovery actually involves. Not the best case. Ask how long until you bear weight, how long until you drive, how long until you are back in normal shoes, and how long until you return to the activity you care about.
What could go wrong. Any surgeon should be able to tell you the specific complications associated with your procedure and how often they occur in their own practice.
Who handles the follow-up. Find out whether the surgeon who operates is the one who sees you afterwards.
The full cost, before the date is booked. Ask the practice to check your benefits and tell you the whole figure up front, including anaesthesia and facility fees, rather than discovering it afterwards.
Get a second opinion for anything major. A surgeon confident in their recommendation will not be troubled by it.
Where we stand
Dr. Jordan R. Stewart, DPM, is certified by the American Board of Foot and Ankle Surgery. He completed a three-year surgical residency at Mercy Medical Center and the University of Maryland School of Medicine, including a fellowship in foot and ankle surgery in the Department of Orthopaedics at the University of Maryland School of Medicine. He recommends the least invasive option that will work, and treats surgery as a last resort rather than a first one.
For an evaluation or a second opinion, call (410) 560-2777 or request an appointment online.
