
Smart Footwear Choices for Women

Originally published April 15, 2014.
Women who wear heels regularly often describe the same progression. The shoes feel fine at first. Then there is an ache at the end of the day. Then shooting pain that starts at the ankle and travels up the leg. By the time it is impossible to ignore, the footwear has usually been the cause for a long while.
Two deformities turn up often in patients with years of heel wear: a bony prominence at the back of the heel, sometimes called a pump bump, and Achilles tendinitis. Neither appears overnight, and both are largely preventable with better shoe choices.
That does not mean heels are forbidden. If the occasion calls for them, wear them, and get out of them when the pain starts rather than pushing through. Keep flats or a supportive sandal in your bag for the rest of the evening.
Flats are not automatically the answer
Flats put far less pressure on the ankle than high heels, but they are not comfortable for everyone, and a flat with no arch support can cause its own problems. The point is not height, it is construction.
Look for shoes designed for comfort rather than shoes that merely look comfortable. Walking pumps are a good example: they have enough height to read as professional, but they are built on athletic-shoe principles, with a supported heel and real room for the toes.
Rotate through the week
Wearing the same shoes every day loads the same muscles and tendons in the same way, which is how overuse pain develops. Mix them up. Flats one day, wedges another, since a wedge adds height while spreading support across the whole foot rather than concentrating it. Kitten heels, at three inches or less, another day. Sneakers on the days you will be on your feet most.
For walking, choose laces
For any real distance, the best choice is a laced shoe: sneakers with padded heels and shock absorption, or boots. Laces, and high tops in particular, transfer the weight and control of the shoe into the leg, which takes pressure off the foot itself.
If the pain has already started
Footwear changes prevent problems better than they fix established ones. If you already have heel pain, a bony prominence at the back of the heel, or pain along the Achilles tendon, have it looked at before it limits what you can wear at all.
